|
Srinivasan,
This question is and evergreen.
There is no generic answer except "that depends on".
The service conditions, materials, pressure temperature, loads come into play.
Maybe a simple calculation can demonstrate safety, maybe a comlex stress analysis needs to be made, with thermal, fatigue, ratcheting, and whatever analysis. The Manufacturer of the vessel must demonstrate on paper the safety of the vessel. And the AI must be conviced to accept this (U-2(g)).
Often Division 2 is used as a first starter. But the stress values shall be from Div. 1!
DK
|